“I’m a Doctor, So…”: Physicians’ Culture, Accountability, and Circumcision

I attended Palm Springs Pride as a volunteer with the Genital Autonomy Legal Defense and Education Fund (GALDEF), and I want to tell you about a festival attendee who visited the booth.

A beautiful drag queen pretends to angrily choke me in front of a booth at Palm Springs Pride. The queen, Rock M. Sakura, is wearing a blue and gray outfit with bows, feathers, and large graphic eye makeup. I am wearing a gay liberation front manifesto shirt and smiling uncontrollably like a dweeb.

NO! No, sorry, not world famous drag queen and Drag Race star Rock M. Sakura. This isn’t about her. I mean, yes, it’s true, she was the highlight of Palm Springs Pride, and we are all thinking “How could we possibly not talk about her?”, and yet we must move on because the person that this post is about is a physician, not a drag queen, although both people seemed very interested in choking me for some reason.

In seriousness, the physician who this post is about spoke a single sentence to me before sprinting away, and in that sentence he revealed a deep truth about the culture of doctors and medicine. My argument in this post is that American physicians don’t defend non-consensual circumcision because of evidence (despite a lot of wasted breath toward that end). I argue that physicians defend medicalized genital cutting because physicians want to believe themselves to be morally good people, and they want to believe parents are morally good people. Medicine shapes its trainees through humiliation and harassment and rewards loyalty to “the way it is done.” Doctors who have been shaped that way treat circumcision sufferers with contempt instead of curiosity, and a profession that can’t hear criticism can’t take accountability. Accountability is about correcting errors, repairing harm, and healing from trauma, but the very way that doctors are formed and molded prevents them from taking accountability for the harm they do to patients.

In Case You’re New Here

Hi, I’m T. T. Perry, Ph.D., and for the last three years I have dedicated myself to understanding biomedicine and how debates unfold, escalate, and resolve. This is my fourth post in my series about accountability from American physicians for their forced genital cutting of children. Check out my other work here:

  1. The AAP Needs a Unified Position on Genital Modifications
  2. Accountability is Not a Useless Sacrifice
  3. Experts on Circumcision: “Not a Medical Procedure”

Besides my series on accountability, I also share my original research on my blog, such as my poster at GLMA’s 2025 conference or my talk at the 2026 Intact Global conference or my amicus brief about intersex genital autonomy filed in Hadachek v. Oregon.

Countertransference of Physicians

Let’s go back to Palm Springs Pride. An older man approached the table and squinted at the literature and signage. Let’s call him the Elder Physician. What was the Elder Physician seeing? The sign conveys that we are an organization seeking to end childhood genital cutting. Our literature covers a diverse range of topics, including consent and regret, intersex people and nonbinary models of sex/gender, sexual health information for new parents about the intact penis, and religious people rejecting forced genital cutting in favor of nonviolent child-welcoming ceremonies. I began to give my usual introductory spiel. “Hi, we’re GALDEF and our mission—”

The Elder Physician interrupted me: “I’m a doctor, so obviously I’m against everything you’re doing.” Then he hurried away. I was so stunned at the sheer absurdity of his words that I couldn’t help but laugh. What in the world just happened?

One explanation of the Elder Physician’s behavior can be found in the idea of countertransference from psychology. Countertransference is the clinician’s own emotional reaction to a client. Typically countertransference is understood to be part of the therapist-client relationship in talk therapy, but the concept of countertransference can be applied to the physician-patient relationship as well (Centeno-Gándara, 2021). When a doctor is reacting emotionally to the information a patient is conveying about their body, sometimes the doctor’s emotions are unconnected to the present reality. Instead, sometimes the doctor’s emotions are triggered by their unresolved feelings and unconscious biases that have been shaped by the doctor’s own past experiences and self-concept.

Countertransference can be further subcategorized. When countertransference arises because of the clinician’s own unresolved issues, it is called subjective, and when countertransference manifests as the clinician acting in a critical, punishing, or contemptuous way, it is called negative countertransference (Tishby, 2022). When the Elder Physician was melting down at Pride, he invoked his identity as a doctor and then linked that with his disapproval of GALDEF, before he had any real opportunity to learn about what GALDEF does. His reaction was not about me or about GALDEF. He was reacting to his own unresolved issues from his past by lashing out at victims of medical violence. His hit-and-run was an attempt to dominate and denigrate someone whose presence triggered feelings of guilt and shame.

This is far from the first time that a physician has reacted with extreme egocentric defensiveness when confronted by people harmed by circumcision. When I was a child, I began foreskin restoration on my own. When my parents discovered this, they coerced me into asking my pediatrician about foreskin restoration. At the appointment, I told my pediatrician what I was doing, and what was his reaction? He sexually assaulted me while telling me the only thing he could ever do to help me was circumcise me again. That is another example of negative subjective countertransference, and there are countless other people with stories just like this. Therapists, physicians, and parents react with callousness, hate, or even violence when confronted by clients, patients, and children who feel harmed by forced genital cutting.

Reproducing a Culture of Non-Consent

Thinking about the Elder Physician and countertransference led me back to Howard F. Stein’s book, American Medicine as Culture. The book’s introduction presents the transference and countertransference that occur in the patient-clinician relationship as the engine which drives the culture of American medicine. Stein writes, “both terms refer to perceiving, feeling, and acting toward current persons as though one were reliving the tribulations and passions of one’s formative, childhood experiences. These unwitting processes serve deep, out-of-awareness purposes for the management of anxiety, which is one of the main functions of culture” (p 2).

Looking at the Elder Physician and my own pediatrician as just two isolated examples of negative subjective countertransference could be a useful approach, but Stein’s book demonstrates how we can connect the aggressive reactions of individual physicians to larger questions about medicine, culture, and politics. Stein writes, “In this book, I focus on group and even wider cultural dynamics that in effect institutionalize the physician’s avoidance of emotional and cultural issues by paradoxically acting out emotion-driven responses to patients. The further cultural paradox of biomedicine is that it insists that it is beyond culture and that the patient’s culture is for the most part inconsequential to diagnosis and treatment” (p 22). I won’t turn my writing into yet another book report, but I will say that anyone interested in understanding the “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) movement would be wise to read Stein’s well-researched ethnography.

One last thing from Stein’s book (I can’t help myself): he summarizes a line of research showing that medical training itself induces anxiety and institutionalizes programs of reaction as “solutions” for that anxiety: “For instance, a common teaching technique called pimping, analogous to learning by degradation in military boot camp, creates an interpersonal or group atmosphere of terror as a means of teaching clinical content and attitude. Pimping, which occurs throughout medical school, internship, and residency, subjects the young doctor to verbal attack from his or her superiors, who often try to humiliate the young physician in the presence of other medical colleagues by relentlessly searching for his or her ‘weak spots’ in knowledge or technique. The fear of being ‘one down,’ at the mercy of another—a patient, a supervisor, another physician, an administrator—leads to perpetual vigilance, to the revenge-tinged attempt always to be ‘one up,’ and to aggressive action when the clinician winds up in the ‘passive’ position. The dread of helplessness and uncertainty helps seal the identification with the aggressor and with it the professional attitude. The dread may later trigger clinical cascades in patient care” (p 51).

Stein’s book was first published in 1990, yet the culture of American medicine remains one of pervasive harassment and bad sexual ethics. A research study of intern physicians found that the majority of doctors surveyed experienced some form of sexual harassment during their first year on the job (Frank, Zhao, and Fang, 2024). It is hard to see how a profession that tolerates so much abuse and harassment under the guise of education could ever come to terms with its own systematic sexual battery of patients. Instead of this current shitty world we live in, where our doctors-in-training are sexually harassed on the job and coerced into cutting infants on the circumstraint, can we imagine a culture of medicine where doctors are experts on the practice of consent, preventing sexual assault, and promoting sexual citizenship?

Docile Doctors and Ideology

One of the many large obstacles to reforming American medicine is convincing physicians that there are serious problems worthy of reform. To make this point, I’ll refer to Carl Elliott, as quoted in Eric Reinhart’s recent paper about docile doctors: “As the historian Carl Elliott has noted in his work on academic medicine’s intolerance for ethical dissent, ‘a central aim of medical training is to transform your sensibility’ and to elicit an automatic thought that, regardless of whatever horrible acts we may watch our colleagues and superiors commit, ‘this is the way it is done’ (Elliott, 2024, as cited in Reinhart, 2025). Moreover, if this is the way that our profession does something, it must be morally good, because at the foundation of the medical profession is a belief that it is underpinned by moral virtue” (Reinhart, 2025).

To understand why America persists as a genital-cutting culture, we have to pick apart the ideology of American medicine. As Reinhart points out, a culture of unquestioning patriarchal worship of one’s superiors (what we might call transference) is embedded in the Hippocratic Oath itself: “I will love those who taught me these arts as I love my parents” (Reinhart, 2025). Given how deeply this attitude is ingrained in medical training, is it really surprising that physicians struggle to discern loyalty from ethics, especially when it comes to medicalized patriarchal sexual violence? Reinhart continues, “U.S. medicine as an ideological apparatus interweaves economic and moral self-interest. It takes advantage of the necessarily institutional basis of effective modern healthcare to align doctors with existing systems and with the perpetuation of America’s for-profit healthcare industry, despite the harm it inflicts. … American medical ideology does this in part by discouraging both critique of and ethical dissent against the economic systems and moral norms upon which the profession is based” (Reinhart, 2025).

The Elder Physician might have been speaking from a place of displaced reactivity, but he said something deeply true in his emotional outburst. He didn’t need to read my zine about nonbinary models of sex/gender and intersex people. He just knew that being a doctor meant being “against us,” and he knew it before any information or evidence changed hands. Read his sentence again and notice whether it is evidence or identity that is propping up the Elder Physician’s thinking: “I’m a doctor, so obviously I’m against everything you’re doing.” The Elder Physician’s resistance to my human rights arises from what gave him his identity as a doctor: the years of pimping and humiliation, the oath to love one’s teachers as one loves one’s parents, the reflex that whatever one’s superiors do must be “the way it is done” and therefore must be good.

Imagine if the Elder Physician had finished his sentence differently: “I’m a doctor, so I’d like to understand how my patients feel about what I’ve done to them.” I cannot help but imagine how different my life would be if my own pediatrician had addressed me with care instead of violence. Being able to speak empathically with patients who’ve endured unnecessary and non-consensual genital cutting does not require a physician to give up medicine; it requires a physician to bear being told he or she caused harm. In other words, it requires a culture of medicine capable of accountability. Whenever American physicians are ready to stop running away from the people they’ve hurt, I’ll be here to help.

References (Order of Appearance)

  1. Centeno-Gándara, L. A. (2021). Improving the physician-patient relationship utilizing psychodynamic psychology: a primer for health professionals. Health Psychology and Behavioral Medicine, 9(1), 338-349.
  2. Tishby, O. (2022). Countertransference—Introduction to a special section. Psychotherapy Research, 32(1), 1-2.
  3. Frank, E., Zhao, Z., Fang, Y., Cleary, J. L., Viglianti, E. M., Sen, S., & Guille, C. (2024, March). Trends in sexual harassment prevalence and recognition during intern year. In JAMA Health Forum (Vol. 5, No. 3, pp. e240139-e240139). American Medical Association.
  4. Reinhart, E. (2025). On medical ideology and the production of docile doctors: The politics of care in an age of authoritarianism. Social Science & Medicine, 118428.
  5. Elliott, C. (2024). In medicine, the morally unthinkable too easily comes to seem normal. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/07/opinion/medical-ethics-dissent.html